
FOMC Holds Rates at 3.5-3.75% Amid Three Dissents While ECB Signals September Hike
Central banks on both sides of the Atlantic plan further tightening despite sub-trend growth, moderating credit, and monetary aggregates aligned with nominal GDP rather than excess demand. Data from Federal Reserve H.8 releases and ECB bank lending surveys show the inflation impulse stems from energy and fiscal channels, not private borrowing. Additional rate increases risk amplifying contraction without addressing root causes.
U.S. Q2 GDP expanded at a 1.5% annual rate while nonfarm payrolls declined 23,000 in July. Euro area growth excluding Ireland reached only 0.3% in Q2 with the Eurosystem projecting 0.8% for the full year. Commercial and industrial loan growth fell from 15.8% annualized in April to minus 1.1% in July per Federal Reserve H.8 data, and euro area M3 expanded 3.4% year-on-year against nominal GDP growth near 4%.
Bank lending surveys show tightening standards already underway without further policy action. U.S. M2 at $23.22 trillion reflects Treasury issuance accommodation rather than private credit expansion, with the reverse repo facility near zero and reserves at $2.94 trillion. Euro area bank claims on governments contracted 0.5%. Headline CPI eased to 3.4% in the U.S. and 2.9% in the euro area while energy shocks and fiscal deficits remain the primary drivers.
The policy response targets private sector activity that shows no excess, risking contraction in already decelerating consumer spending and business investment. Both central banks treat imported price pressures as demand-driven despite flat federal spending and unemployment at 6.3% in the euro area.
September decisions will hinge on August CPI and employment prints; persistent weakness in loan demand and money aggregates below trend growth points to unchanged or lower policy rates rather than hikes.
FOMC: No September hike occurs as core CPI remains at or below 2.5% and job growth stays below 150k monthly average through Q4 2023.
Sources (3)
- [1]Federal Reserve H.8 Assets and Liabilities of Commercial Banks(https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h8/)
- [2]ECB Monetary Statistics July 2023(https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/pr/stats/md/html/index.en.html)
- [3]Eurostat GDP and Unemployment Data Q2 2023(https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat)