10-Year RCT Finds Fruits and Vegetables Cut Hospitalizations 78% Versus Usual Care in Stage 3 CKD
A 10-year RCT showed fruits and vegetables for dietary acid reduction in stage 3 CKD outperformed sodium bicarbonate and usual care on hospitalizations, ED visits, and dialysis progression without added cost. Prior short-term studies are extended by these hard outcomes, but small single-center data need larger confirmation.
The trial randomized 36 patients each to fruits and vegetables targeting 50% dietary acid reduction, oral sodium bicarbonate at equivalent dose, or usual care, with annual follow-up for a decade. Primary clinical events included 115 total hospitalizations, 166 emergency visits, and 34 dialysis initiations. The diet arm showed 20 emergency visits and 4 dialysis cases versus 88 visits and 16 dialysis cases in usual care; bicarbonate produced no separation from usual care on any endpoint. No increase in overall health-system costs was reported for the diet group.
Prior Goraya-led studies from 2012-2014 demonstrated short-term bicarbonate-equivalent effects on GFR preservation with base-producing foods, yet lacked decade-long hard outcomes. This extension reveals downstream utilization benefits that medication arms failed to match, suggesting mechanisms beyond simple acid neutralization such as potassium or fiber effects on inflammation. The single-center design and modest sample limit generalizability, while the 10-year retention strengthens causal inference for the observed divergence.
Next steps require multicenter replication with blinded endpoint adjudication and formal cost-effectiveness modeling before KDIGO guideline updates. Population-level produce prescriptions could amplify gains if scalable without raising net expenditure.
Nimrit Goraya: Multicenter trial of 500+ patients will show at least 40% relative reduction in 5-year dialysis incidence by 2032.
Sources (3)
- [1]ASN Kidney Week 2026 Abstract: Goraya et al.(https://www.asn-online.org/education/kidneyweek/2026)
- [2]Goraya N et al. Am J Nephrol 2014; Dietary acid reduction with fruits and vegetables(https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25059841)
- [3]MedicalXpress coverage of trial(https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-10-fruits-vegetables-outperform-medication-metabolic.html)