
Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook Android photo access
Italian regulators fined Meta €805 million for accessing Android users' photos, videos and metadata without specific consent, citing a default feature and inadequate notice. The case shows how privacy rules can convert ordinary app permissions into large regulatory exposure and affects tens of millions of users whose personal media may be scanned or used without clear opt-in.
Italian regulators on Nov. 14 fined Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd €805 million, about $887 million, for the Facebook Android feature called Get camera roll suggestions when you are browsing Facebook. The Italian Data Protection Authority said the app accessed photographs, videos and related metadata stored on users' smartphones without specific consent and without adequate notice. The regulator ordered Meta to disable the feature within 60 days and to seek separate consent if it wants to use it again.
The authority said the fine, about 0.47 percent of Meta's global turnover, reflected the breach duration, the number of people affected and Meta's poor level of cooperation during the investigation. It began the case in July last year and found the Facebook app sought only one permission to access the gallery, then used that access for other functions with different needs. The feature was switched on by default, and once permission was granted the app could read the entire photo archive stored on the device.
The ruling rests on Article 122 of Italy's privacy code, which treats a smartphone as part of the private sphere. The authority said any access to information stored on such devices requires free and informed consent, regardless of whether data is transmitted or harm occurs. Meta challenged Italy's jurisdiction and said it would appeal, calling the fine disproportionate. A Meta spokesperson said users must grant permission before the feature operates and can change it in settings, framing it as a simple sharing tool.
The decision affects almost 20 million Android users in Italy and targets a permission model that can turn one gallery grant into broad access to personal media. It also arrives as Meta faces other privacy litigation in the United States. A New Mexico judge on Oct. 21 ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury found 43.9 million violations of state consumer protection law tied to misleading statements about data sharing, a case rooted in disclosures from the Cambridge Analytica scandal.
It affects Android users in Italy and other platforms relying on broad photo permissions, because regulators can treat silent access to personal media as a violation even when users granted a single gallery permission.
Sources (1)
- [1]Italy Slaps Meta With $880 Million Fine Over What Facebook Was Doing With Your Phone's Photos(https://www.zerohedge.com/technology/italy-slaps-meta-880-million-fine-over-what-facebook-was-doing-your-phones-photos)