Report says almost a third of Amazon Black Friday deals gave no savings over two years
A report says nearly one-third of Amazon Black Friday deals over two years offered no savings, prompting Amazon to dispute the finding. The issue turns on whether promotional prices beat recent normal prices, not just whether a discount label appears. It matters because it affects how much consumers actually save during major shopping events.
Amazon's Black Friday promotions were examined across two years, and the report found nearly one in three offers did not reduce the price relative to the item's recent normal price. The finding targets one of the largest online shopping events of the year, when retailers use discounts to drive traffic and consumers plan purchases around advertised price cuts. Amazon pushed back against the report, saying the conclusion does not reflect the value it offers customers.
The report's central number is that almost one-third of deals in the two-year sample produced no savings, according to its analysis of price data. The exact share can vary by product category, seller, and timing, because online prices change frequently and retailers often use limited-time offers, coupons, or bundled discounts. The report treats a deal as offering no savings when the promotional price does not beat a recent baseline, even if the item is labeled discounted.
The dispute is about measurement, not just marketing. A discount can be real if it is lower than the prevailing price just before the sale, but weak if retailers raise prices beforehand or if the same price appears regularly. Amazon's scale makes the issue material: it is a primary venue for household spending, and its pricing algorithms and third-party sellers create a moving target. The report therefore matters less as proof of fraud than as a test of whether advertised discounts track actual price history.
For shoppers, the finding cuts directly into the main reason to wait for Black Friday: the expectation that a visible discount means a lower final price. If a third of deals do not beat a recent baseline, buyers may pay full price while believing they are saving, which shifts value from consumers to retailers and sellers. The stakes are broad because the same discount logic shapes other sales events, from back-to-school promotions to holiday gift buying.
Consumers relying on Black Friday labels may pay prices that are not lower than recent baseline prices. The finding affects household spending and trust in promotional discounts across major retail sales events.
Sources (1)
- [1]Original source(https://www.marketwatch.com/story/do-amazons-black-friday-deals-really-save-you-money-03859cf3?mod=mw_rss_topstories)