
UK Ministry of Justice is withholding nationality-by-offence conviction figures, citing privacy, while appealing an order to release them
The Information Commissioner ordered the Ministry of Justice to release 2018–2024 conviction counts by nationality and offence, suppressing cells under five. The department is appealing, arguing cost and a risk that detailed tables could identify offenders. A further 2025 breakdown has also been refused, according to the requester. Broader official series already exist, and they do not show a simple overall over-representation of non-citizens in convictions — but they also do not answer the offence-level question the withheld tables would.
Documented: The UK Information Commissioner’s Office ruled on 22 June 2026, in decision notice IC-416928-D9J8, that the Ministry of Justice must disclose conviction totals for England and Wales broken down by nationality and offence category. The Commissioner found the department had not shown that compiling the data would exceed Freedom of Information cost limits, and that data-protection exemptions applied only to cells with fewer than five cases. Counts of five or above, the notice says, were not personal data because identification was not likely. The MoJ has appealed that order to the First-tier Tribunal (FT/EA/2026/0269). The request came from the Centre for Migration Control and covers 2018–2024, including violence, sexual offences, drugs, weapons, theft and robbery, with small numbers already proposed for suppression.
Documented in court papers reported by GB News: the department argues that the interests and fundamental rights of the people the statistics describe outweigh the legitimate interest in disclosure, and that combining nationality and offence counts with open-court reporting could identify individuals — a “mosaic effect.” Robert Bates, the group’s director, calls that paradoxical because convictions are already public under open justice, and has alleged inconsistent cost estimates. That allegation is his; the tribunal has not ruled on it. The Spectator reported that the appeal was launched under then-Justice Secretary David Lammy and that the department told the magazine it does not regard the case as a cover-up and does not comment on live proceedings. Brussels Signal reported that successor Alex Norris had, as of mid-August 2026, left the appeal in place.
Claimed, and not independently reproduced here from the refusal letter: that a separate 2025 request was refused with the line that data subjects’ interest in safeguarding personal information outweighed the public interest, and that disclosure could identify individuals. The Centre for Migration Control states on its own site that 2025 figures have also been refused, so that eight years are now withheld. That is the requester’s account of the department’s position.
What the state already publishes is narrower. Home Office immigration-system statistics cover foreign national offenders in detention and returns, with nationality and broad offence groups for some of those cohorts — not a full conviction census by nationality and detailed offence. A government spokesperson, quoted by GB News, said nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders had been removed since July 2024, up 41 percent, and that the law had been changed so foreign prisoners can be deported earlier. The Ministry of Justice also publishes prison snapshots and cautions-and-convictions by broad nationality group.
The gap is real, and so is the risk of over-reading what partial figures already show. Oxford’s Migration Observatory, using official series, reports that non-UK citizens accounted for about 13.1 percent of cautions and convictions in 2024 and 12.1 percent of the prison population in June 2025 — roughly in line with an estimated non-citizen share of the adult population — while their share of prison entries was higher, at 18.7 percent in 2025. Age structure matters: non-citizens are younger, and offending is concentrated among young men. Nationality is not immigration status. A foreign national in the statistics may have arrived as a child, on a work visa, as a student, as a refugee, or without status. Earlier Telegraph reporting, based on other FOI releases rather than the contested dataset, found foreign nationals over-represented in sexual-offence convictions in 2021–23 relative to population share, with large differences between nationalities. Those findings are not a substitute for the series the Commissioner ordered released, and they do not by themselves establish rates for asylum arrivals or for specific crimes such as rape or child sexual abuse.
Speculated, not shown: that the appeal exists because ministers already know a particular nationality pattern and are concealing it to protect a migration policy. Campaigners and some commentators infer motive from the length of the fight. The documented record shows a legal dispute over cost and identification risk, a regulator that rejected both grounds for counts of five or more, and a department that is spending public money to keep that ruling from taking effect while pointing to deportation totals as its transparency substitute. Whether privacy law, properly applied to aggregated justice statistics, requires that substitute is what the tribunal is for. Until it rules, the public can see broad foreign-offender shares and removal numbers, and cannot see the offence-level nationality table an independent regulator has already said should be published.
People in England and Wales are being asked to judge crime and migration policy without the offence-level nationality tables an independent regulator has already said should be released. Until the tribunal decides, victims, researchers and voters have removal totals and broad shares, not the breakdown the Ministry of Justice is spending to withhold.
Sources (7)
- [1]ICO decision notice IC-416928-D9J8, Ministry of Justice(https://ico.org.uk/action-weve-taken/decision-notices/2026/06/ic-416928-d9j8/)
- [2]What is the MoJ hiding about migrant crime? — The Spectator(https://spectator.com/article/what-is-the-moj-hiding-about-migrant-crime/)
- [3]Labour argues migrant criminals' rights outweigh public interest — GB News(https://www.gbnews.com/news/migrant-crime-labour-public-interest)
- [4]Britain’s new justice secretary maintains legal fight to block conviction data by nationality — Brussels Signal(https://brusselssignal.eu/2026/08/britains-new-justice-secretary-maintains-legal-fight-to-block-uk-conviction-data-by-nationality/)
- [5]Centre for Migration Control on the withheld conviction series(https://centreformigrationcontrol.com/analysis/69-percent-brits-want-foreign-criminals-deported)
- [6]Migrants and crime in the UK — Migration Observatory(https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/migrants-and-crime-in-the-uk/)
- [7]Statistics on foreign national offenders and the immigration system — GOV.UK(https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/statistics-on-foreign-national-offenders-and-the-immigration-system/statistics-on-foreign-national-offenders-and-the-immigration-system)