Astronomy historian links four tools and sites to European colonization in Americas and Hawai'i
Gregg Wade's arXiv preprint argues that European astronomy supported colonization in the Americas and Hawai'i through four case studies: a marine chronometer, an astronomical surveying quadrant, the Nautical Almanac and Maunakea observatories. It matters because it connects scientific tools and institutions to navigation, territorial mapping, colonial authority and Indigenous land disputes.
Wade’s paper, posted on arXiv, reframes European astronomy not as a neutral record of discovery but as a set of practices that helped make colonial control possible. He examines four examples: a marine chronometer, an astronomical surveying quadrant, the Nautical Almanac, and contemporary observatories on Maunakea. Each is treated as a material or visual object whose use extended beyond science into navigation, land measurement, sea power and place-making. The argument is that these tools carried authority and helped translate distant territories into administrable space.
The evidence is interpretive rather than statistical: Wade reads instruments, publications and landscape cases as historical traces. The chronometer and quadrant show how precise time and angle measurement could make position at sea and on land more reliable. The Nautical Almanac systematized data for navigation, while Maunakea observatories connect modern scientific prestige to contested Indigenous land. The paper’s method is close reading of four selected cases, with a sample size of four, so it builds a pattern through illustration rather than broad measurement.
This sits within a broader reassessment of how science has been entangled with empire, from cartography and census-taking to botany and surveying. Astronomy is a pointed case because it supplies universal coordinates: time, longitude, latitude and celestial reference points. Those coordinates can support safe voyages, but they also support claims about ownership, boundaries and jurisdiction. By centering Indigenous Knowledges and Perspectives, Wade asks whether the familiar story of progress can be told alongside histories of dispossession, surveillance and land control.
The stakes are present-day and institutional. If observatories, navigation systems and public science narratives are understood as part of colonial histories, museums, universities and heritage sites may need to reinterpret exhibits, land agreements and public memory. For Indigenous communities in the Americas and Hawai'i, the paper speaks to ongoing disputes over land, sovereignty and whose knowledge counts. The main limitation is that the preprint is not peer-reviewed and rests on four cases, so stronger evidence would require wider archives, community testimony and comparative data.
It affects how museums, universities and heritage institutions interpret astronomical tools and sites, and it speaks to Indigenous communities whose land and knowledge histories are tied to colonial science.
Sources (1)
- [1]Different Stories: European Astronomy as a Tool of Colonization in the Americas and Hawai'i(https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21687)