University of Bath study challenges 1972 hypothesis that essential genes mutate more slowly
Researchers at the University of Bath analyzed spontaneous mutations in E. coli and yeast to test a 1972 hypothesis that essential genes mutate more slowly. They concluded that earlier patterns likely reflect natural selection removing harmful mutations, not evolved protection of important genes. The result affects how scientists interpret mutation data and the randomness of evolutionary change.
Researchers at the University of Bath published a study in PLOS Biology challenging a hypothesis first proposed in 1972 that organisms can evolve lower mutation rates in genes essential for survival. Led by Dr Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence Hurst, the team examined spontaneous mutations in two microorganisms, the bacterium E. coli and baker's yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The work tests whether important genes mutate more slowly than less important ones, a claim that has attracted repeated scientific attention since the 1970s and again in 2023.
The analysis used the largest collection of spontaneous genetic mutations assembled to date, according to the study's account, to compare mutation occurrence across genes of different biological importance. Instead of finding a clear protective effect in essential genes, the authors concluded that earlier evidence supporting slower mutation in important genes was misleading. They argue that harmful mutations in essential genes are rapidly removed from populations by natural selection, making those genes appear quieter than they really are. In that view, the apparent reduction is an artifact of selection acting after mutation, not a mutation-suppression mechanism.
The finding strikes at a long-running debate about how random mutation is in evolution. The standard model treats mutations as raw variation, with selection filtering which changes persist. The alternative idea, that organisms might bias mutation toward less critical regions, is intuitively attractive because mutations in core cellular machinery can be lethal. Yet the Bath team notes that mutations in individual genes are already rare, so further reducing them may offer too little benefit for selection to favor. The new analysis reframes the pattern as survivorship bias in observed mutations.
The result matters for how biologists interpret genetic variation and design experiments on evolution, antibiotic resistance, and disease. If important genes are not protected by lower mutation rates, apparent differences may reflect selection removing harmful changes rather than evolved control over mutation. The methods note: the analysis used the largest spontaneous mutation collection assembled to date, but the source does not give a numeric sample size, and it centers on E. coli and yeast.
The finding changes how researchers read mutation patterns in genes tied to survival, disease, and antibiotic resistance. It suggests apparent protection of essential genes may be an observational effect of selection, not a biological mechanism.
Sources (1)
- [1]Original source(https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/11/261119194538.htm)